The Crow. A neighbor close by the Pacific Ocean. Very social and caring creatures

Liz and Lee Heidhues 1.1.2022

The Crow is on Maleficent’s shoulder in Sleeping Beauty.

Crows are secretive and can count. Most Crows can count to three.

What are these birds up to?

Dressed as for a funeral, caw-caw-cawing, the Crows in our backyard have become tame. The Crows mess around in our dog’s water bowls.

The Cherokee word for Crow is “koga.” Koga acquired its black color in a futile attempt to acquire the first fire.

Loud, rambunctious, and highly intelligent, Crows are most often associated with a long history of fear and loathing. Crow’s black feathers associate them with Death.

Research has demonstrated Crows are actually very social and caring creatures and also among the smartest animals on the Planet.

The Crow also has a dark place in American culture. The 1994 film The Crow was forever cursed when Brandon Lee, son of martial arts icon Bruce Lee, died after being accidentally wounded by a prop gun during filming. The movie was released after his death and has become a Cult classic. This tragic accident has led many people to believe to this day the film was cursed.

The critical consensus states: “Filled with style and dark, lurid energy, The Crow is an action-packed visual feast that also has a soul in the performance of the late Brandon Lee.”[

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Crow_(1994_film)

The following photo montage shows The Crow in a more benign setting as a good neighbor and source of entertainment.

8-cawfka.jpg

16 Cawfkas.jpg

24-cawfka-liz.png

14 Cawfka

29-cawfka-liz.jpg

15-cawfkas.jpg

30-cawfka-liz.jpg

25 Cawfka Liz

Photos – Liz and Lee Heidhues

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_crow

34-the-crow.jpg
A still from The Crow – 1994. Cult classic film. Alex Proyas director
36-the-crow.jpg
This soundtrack is dedicated to the memory of Brandon Lee.

35 The Crow.jpg

 

 

 

 

 

 

Motorcycle down in the mayhem on treacherous streets of San Francisco

December 30, 2021

Every Picture Tells a Story – Motorcycle down on the streets of outer San Francisco

Walking to the grocery store this afternoon I came upon this post mayhem scene in the outer Richmond District. I missed the moment of impact but it’s obvious that the motorcycle got the worst of it. 

The motorcycle rider was nowhere to be seen. The SFPD was out in force to survey and analyze the carnage at 36th Avenue and Geary Boulevard.

Photos – Lee Heidhues

motorcyle-down-iii-12.30.2021.jpg

motorcyle-down-v-12.30.2021.jpg

Motorcyle down IV 12.30.2021.jpg

Motorcyle down VI 12.30.2021

motorcyle-down-ii-12.30.2021.jpg

Patti Smith -“Christ died for somebody’s sins, but not mine…” – an enigma at age 75

The American media isn’t celebrating Patti Smith on her 75th birthday. It should. She’s an icon born in Chicago, raised in New Jersey and has become world reknown for her music and writing.  

Patti Smith has now reached the world of advertising and can be seen modeling for Rimowa luggage as she continues to reinvent herself.

Patti Smith V.jpg
Patti Smith carries the Rimowa brand

Excerpted from Deutsche Welle 12.29.2021

Some have called her the Godmother of Punk, others the Grande Dame of Alternative Rock. But what Patti Smith really is, deep down in her heart, is a poet. Her music takes second.

Born on December, 30, 1946, in Chicago, Smith grew up in New Jersey together with three siblings. While her father was an atheist, her mother was a Jehovah’s Witness, raising her kids to be religious.

She wanted to become a teacher. During her studies, she got pregnant and had the baby, but gave it up for adoption. Then she quit her studies, and – not even 20 years old – found her way to New York’s art scene where she got involved in art, drugs, parties and music.

Back then, her idols were the poets Charles Baudelaire and Arthur Rimbaud, and the musicians Jimi Hendrix, Brian Jones and Jim Morrison.

Patti Smith III 12.29.2021.jpg

In clubs and bars, Smith opened for rock bands by reciting her poems on stage. She had her first big performance in February 1971. As part of a planned poetry series, Smith recited her work for New York stars like Allen Ginsberg, Andy Warhol, Lou Reed, Sam Shepherd and others, eventually publishing two volumes of poetry.

During that time she also jammed with guitarist Lenny Kaye and keyboarder Richard Sohl.

The three musicians kept playing around with Van Morrison’s song “Gloria” for a long time until Smith decided to work in her famous poem “Oath” into that song:

“Christ died for somebody’s sins, but not mine (…) Christ, I’m giving you the goodbye, firing you tonight. I can make my own light shine.”

The reference to her mother’s suffocating religiosity could not be overlooked.

Patti Smith I 12.29.2021.jpg

In 1975, the Patti Smith Group was complete. The first album, “Horses,” was created with the help of producer and Velvet Underground veteran John Cale. On the cover, Smith appeared almost like an androgynous being with a wild dark mane – slim, delicate, clad in a men’s shirt and jacket, and wearing a black ribbon looking like a loose tie.

Reacting to Smith’s wild performances, the music world put her squarely in the punk box, and even called her the Godmother of Punk. In an interview with BBC, she later said she regretted having been given all kinds of titles, like “princess of piss,” or “wild rock ‘n’ roll mustang.”

Patti Smith IV 12.29.2021.jpg
Patti Smith with Bob Dylan

After a fade in the 1980’s Bob Dylan brought her back into the limelight in the mid-1990’s. Smith reactivated her old band, and before they knew it they were opening for Dylan’s show. The audience was thrilled. Twenty years after the release of “Horses,” the band returned into the studio to produce the album “Gone Again” – a collection of somber and touching songs in memory of her deceased husband.

Patti Smith Just Kids VII.jpg
Patti Smith’s autobiography Just Kids. Winner of a 2010 National Book Award – pictured with Robert Mapplethorpe

Smith still continues to produce music today. Her wild mane has turned grey but the power of her songs hasn’t diminished a bit. Whether she sings her old hits attempts to cover rock classics like “Smells like Teen Spirit” by Nirvana, she remains a poet who transports her verses via music.

https://www.dw.com/en/patti-smith-poet-with-a-punk-heart-turns-75/a-36957499

Time for advocates of car free spaces in San Francisco to join the Court battle

Attn:  All Hands on Deck to preserve car free spaces in San Francisco.

The plaintiffs in the lawsuit to force the opening to cars of The Great Walkway, JFK Drive and MLK Drive have filed a Motion for a Preliminary Injunction forcing the City to open these thoroughfares to cars IMMEDIATELY.

The Motion will be heard in Dept. 302 on January 31, 2022 at 9:30AM.

The Open the Great Highway Alliance is hoping the Court approves their Motion because it would put cars back onto these currently car free spaces while the lawsuit is litigated.

3-great-walkway-11.23.2021.jpg
The bright lights of a car on The Great Walkway 11.23.2021
Great Highway III
Car free Great Walkway 9.9.2020

Motion for Injunction Open Great Walkway CPF-21-517641

You can visit the SF Superior Court website and look on the Register of Actions for case CPF-21-517641. It will provide you with all the activity in the lawsuit to date.

The City has yet to make a formal appearance in Court; i.e. an response to the Request for a Writ of Mandate filed December 16, 2021.

Excerpted from San Francisco Chronicle Editorial 12.25.2021

JFK Drive is for people, not car commuters. Let’s keep it that way in 2022 and beyond

24 JFK Car Free 4.11.2021.jpg
Car Free JFK Drive rally 4.11.2021

Before the pandemic, JFK was one of the most dangerous and deadliest streets in San Francisco. There were 91 crashes on it from 2014 through its 2020 closure. That’s mostly because 75% of people traveling on JFK had no intention of visiting the park; they were simply using it as a cut-through.

This would be a policy failure for any city; for a supposedly transit-first city like San Francisco, however, it was an inexcusable display of incompetence.

Few would object to a gentle street through Golden Gate Park that enables slow, but convenient vehicle access, especially for the mobility impaired, to the park’s amenities. But allowing the main thoroughfare of the city’s marquee park to become a high-speed commuter freeway — as it once was — was a gross and too-often deadly civic failure that can never again be allowed to repeat itself.

4 Car free JFK 3.20.2021.jpg
Car free JFK rally signage 3.15.2021

https://www.sfchronicle.com/opinion/openforum/article/Editorial-Keep-JFK-Drive-closed-to-cars-in-2022-16726845.php

Excerpted from San Francisco Chronicle Editorial 9.19.2021

SF jumped the gun in its Great Highway reopening. That can’t happen at JFK

IMG-8773 (002).jpg
Traffic on Chain of Lakes Drive on a weekday rush hour when The Great Walkway is open to cars. 10.6.2021
2-chain-of-lakes-11.23.2021.jpg
Cars on Chain of Lakes Drive during rush hour 11.23.2021

Anecdotally, traffic on Chain of Lakes — one of the ostensible reasons given for the need to reopen the Great Highway last month, after it had been closed to cars for most of the pandemic — appears as bad or nearly as bad as it was before the reopening. Cars also still appear to be cutting through Outer Sunset neighborhoods in search of shortcuts — in defiance of another rationale given for the necessity of reopening the highway.

Great Highway II 11.15.2020.jpg
The Great Walkway 11.15.2020

https://www.sfchronicle.com/opinion/openforum/article/Editorial-SF-jumped-the-gun-in-its-Great-Highway-16469050.php

Photos – Liz and Lee Heidhues

A bad break. Thumb injury could shelve QB Garoppolo and crush playoff hopes

Lee Heidhues 12.27.2021

The media has been trashing 49ers QB for his poor performance in the 20-17 loss to the Tennessee Titans last Thursday.

It appears there is  definitely a legtimate reason that Jimmy G did not have a standout performance. The Niners QB suffered a serious thumb injury during the second quarter.

Garoppolo may be done for the season. This means the 49ers top draft choice Trey Lance, who has warmed the bench all season, will be thrown into the spotlight against the Houston Texans this Sunday and the season finale against the Los Angeles Rams on January 9.

Excerpted from San Francisco Chronicle 12.27.2021

Quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo suffered an injury to his right thumb in Thursday’s loss to the Titans that has clouded his status for the rest of the 49ers’ season.

Though the team characterized the injury as a sprain, ESPN reported Garoppolo suffered a torn ulnar collateral ligament (located in the lower thumb) and a fracture. Dr. Nirav Pandya, the associate professor of UCSF orthopedic surgery, said that surgery to repair such an injury involves a recovery timeline of four to six weeks.

Jimmy G II 12.27.2021.jpg

Pandya was skeptical Garoppolo could play effectively through the injury if a brace was used to support his thumb. The UCL is key for stability and grip strength.

Asked if Garoppolo’s season is likely over, barring an unforeseen development, Pandya paints a picture in which fans should expect Trey Lance will be the 49ers’ starting QB on Sunday and beyond.

“That would be my guess based on what’s being reported,” Pandya said. “I think it would be very hard for a quarterback to either play at all, or play effectively, with this injury. That would be my educated guess.”

Rookie Trey Lance, the third overall pick of the 2021 NFL draft, will make his second career start if Garoppolo is unable to play against Houston on Sunday at Levi’s Stadium. Lance hasn’t thrown a pass in a game since he started in a 17-10 loss at Arizona on Oct. 10, when Garoppolo was sidelined with a strained calf.

Jimmy G I 12.27.2021.jpg
Jimmy G. Season could be over.

The 49ers (8-7), currently the No. 6 seed in the NFC playoff chase, could need to beat Houston and the Rams in their regular-season finale to secure a postseason berth.

https://www.sfchronicle.com/sports/49ers/article/49ers-Jimmy-Garoppolo-has-sprained-right-16732585.php

I’m a Senior. I’m fed up with Seniors who say the World owes “us” a favor. “Us”?

Lee Heidhues 12.26.2021

The San Francisco Chronicle published a lead editorial vigorously calling for JFK Drive in Golden Gate Park to be designated permanently car free. The predicatable push back from the spoiled Entitled motorists. I refuse to be cowed by these people who seemingly know no other way of life than a Car. Pathetic. The following is posted in the Chronicle reader comments section.

I am beyond fed up with Seniors who believe because of their age that the rest of the World owes “us” a favor. “Us”? My wife and I are setuagenarians Our modes of transit are bicycles, our feet and public transit. It has been that way for our entire relationship.

Stegosaurus 12.26.2021
Entitled Senior 2021. JFK car free opponent. Stegosaurus – San Francisco version

We raised a family in San Francisco and traveled to the Fine Arts Museum with no problems. The two of us still cycle on car free JFK Drive to attend the de Young as long time members.

11-liz-jfk-12.19.2021-1.jpg

For seniors to make their spurious claim they have a right and need to drive and park on JFK Drive is a total non starter. It is selfishness in the extreme. There are thousands upon thousands of others who are enjoying JFK Drive without the need to park their cars on this thoroughfare.

The Seniors, by this unrelenting wailing and faux sense of entitlement, are destroying the future happiness of current and future generations. Life is finite. Think about it and stop the complaining. This comment is directed specifically at never stop kvetching Seniors and their Entitled cheerleaders.

Glad to read the Chronicle is standing up to the Fine Arts Museum aristocracy’s and their camp followers wailing to have cars be permitted on JFK Drive to assist their corporate benefactors. To read The maudlin non stop Entitled motorists kvetch about 1.5 miles of road being car free in a City with 1200 miles of road to drive on. Nobody has a lifetime Permit to drive anywhere anytime irrespective of the faux message being pitched about inconvenience.

4 JFK Holiday 12.19.2021.jpg

Excerpted from San Francisco Chronicle 12.26.2021

Urban theorist Jane Jacobs wrote in her seminal book “Death and Life of Great American Cities” that “the destructive effect of automobiles are much less a cause than a symptom of our incompetence at city building.”

It would be difficult to find a better illustration of this point than San Francisco’s John F. Kennedy Drive prior to its closure to vehicle traffic in April 2020.

Before the pandemic, JFK was one of the most dangerous and deadliest streets in San Francisco. There were 91 crashes on it from 2014 through its 2020 closure. That’s mostly because 75% of people traveling on JFK had no intention of visiting the park; they were simply using it as a cut-through.

16 JFK Car Free Frida Kahlo II 4.11.2021.jpg

This would be a policy failure for any city; for a supposedly transit-first city like San Francisco, however, it was an inexcusable display of incompetence.

Few would object to a gentle street through Golden Gate Park that enables slow, but convenient vehicle access, especially for the mobility impaired, to the park’s amenities. But allowing the main thoroughfare of the city’s marquee park to become a high-speed commuter freeway — as it once was — was a gross and too-often deadly civic failure that can never again be allowed to repeat itself.

63 JFK Car Free 5.24.2021.jpg

To ensure JFK remains a safe and enjoyable space, worthy of one of the most stunning urban parks in the world, it should remain closed to cars in 2022 and beyond.

3 Car free JFK 3.20.2021.jpg

JFK Holiday Announcement II 12.19.2021.jpg

https://www.sfchronicle.com/opinion/openforum/article/Editorial-Keep-JFK-Drive-closed-to-cars-in-2022-16726845.php

Bambi: cute, lovable, vulnerable … or dark parable of Nazi antisemitic terror?

Lee Heidhues 12.25.2021

Sad Surprises never stop. Even on Christmas Day.

I always believed Bambi to be a benign story about kind animals which was brought to life on the big screen by Walt Disney in the classic cartoon.

Now this fantasy story line has gone a glimmering and the story of Bambi will be put before the world in its originally intended fashion. A novel published nearly 100 years ago portrayed the Bambi tale in a more sobering dark light.

Excerpted from The Guardian 12.25.2021

A new translation of Felix Salten’s 1923 novel reasserts its original message that warns of Jewish persecution

Bambi II 12.25.2021.jpg

It’s a saccharine sweet story about a young deer who finds love and friendship in a forest. But the original tale of Bambiadapted by Disney in 1942, has much darker beginnings as an existential novel about persecution and antisemitism in 1920s Austria.

Now, a new translation seeks to reassert the rightful place of Felix Salten’s 1923 masterpiece in adult literature and shine a light on how Salten was trying to warn the world that Jews would be terrorised, dehumanised and murdered in the years to come.

“Bambi does not survive well, at the end. He is alone, totally alone … It is a tragic story about the loneliness and solitude of Jews and other minority groups,” said Jack Zipes, professor emeritus of German and comparative literature at the University of Minnesota and translator of the forthcoming book.

Far from being a children’s story, Bambi was actually a parable about the inhumane treatment and dangerous precariousness of Jews and other minorities in what was then an increasingly fascist world, the new translation will show.

Nazi book burning 12.25.2021.jpg
Nazi Germany book burning – 1935

In 1935, the book was banned by the Nazis, who saw it as a political allegory on the treatment of Jews in Europe and burned it as Jewish propaganda. “The darker side of Bambi has always been there,” said Professor Zipes.

Bambi 12.25.2021.jpg

“But what happens to Bambi at the end of the novel has been concealed, to a certain extent, by the Disney corporation taking over the book and making it into a pathetic, almost stupid film about a prince and a bourgeois family.”

Salten’s novel, Bambi, a Life in the Woods, is completely different he said. “It is a book about survival in your own home.” From the moment he is born, Bambi is under constant threat from hunters who invade the forest and attack indiscriminately. “They kill whatever animal they want.”

It soon becomes apparent that the forest animals are living out their lives in fear and that puts the reader constantly “on edge”: “All the animals have been persecuted. And I think what shakes the reader is that there are also some animals who are traitors, who help the hunters kill.”

Bambi III 12.25.2021.jpg

After Bambi’s mother is murdered, so is his beloved cousin Gobo, who had been led to believe he was special and the hunters would be “kind” to him. Bambi is shot too, but survives thanks to the old prince, a majestic stag who treats him like a son (and may well be his father). But then, sadly, the old prince also dies, leaving Bambi utterly bereft.

https://www.theguardian.com/news/2021/dec/25/bambi-cute-lovable-vulnerable-or-a-dark-parable-of-antisemitic-terror

“Massive but pointless threats” from Israel. Iran fires ‘warning’ to Jewish state

The average American pays scant attention to the volatile and dangerous Middle East.  Or anywhere else in the world for that matter.

The typical American, an isolationist at heart, is too wrapped up in his own concerns about the Pandemic, trying to pay the bills and looking forward to the next football game.

This leaves little time to ponder what happens across the globe allowing the average American to  go blithely on believing events abroad have  no consequence or could have any impact on them.

Admittedly there is a sizable minority of Americans who keep informed about global events. Sadly these people are the exception to what should be the rule.

Excerpted from Deutsche Welle 12.24.2021

An Iranian military chief said that the military exercises were a response to “massive but pointless threats” from Israel. The British government sharply condemned the missile launches.

Iranian missile tests IV 12.24.2021.jpg

Iran has previously said that it’s short and medium-range missiles can reach Israel, as well as US bases in the region.

Military drills conducted this week by Iran were intended to send a warning to Israel, the country’s top military commanders said on Friday.

Iran conducted these drills in the Persian Gulf amid concerns over possible plans by Israel to attack Iranian nuclear sites.

The war games included firing ballistic and cruise missiles. State television showed missiles flattening a target which resembled Israel’s Dimona nuclear reactor.

Why did Iran conduct the military drills?

Iranian missile tests III 12.24.2021.jpg
An Iranian warship test fires a Cruise Missile

Iranian Revolutionary Guards chief General Hossein Salami said this week’s drills were intended to send “a very clear message” and a “serious warning” to regional rival Israel.

“We will cut off their hands if they make a wrong move,” Salami said on state TV.

Armed Forces Chief of Staff Major General Mohammed Bagheri said 16 ballistic missiles of different classes had been fired.

Bagheri said that the drill was an answer to Israel’s recent “massive but pointless threats” to Iran.

Iranian missile tests I 12.24.2021
A missile explosion behind a member of the Iranian national guard

https://www.dw.com/en/iran-fires-missiles-during-drills-in-warning-to-israel/a-60253795

 

In the 1950’s, the era of Red hunter Joe McCarthy, careers were being destroyed

Lee Heidhues 12.21.2021

Most people don’t know or want to forget that the early 1950’s was a horrific paranoid era in America.

It was the time of the Red Scare when paranoia ran amok. The careers of people regardless of their status or income were being destroyed. Why? Because of their political beliefs genuine and imagined by the Red hunters of the day.

The just released film “Being the Ricardos” tells one such story. Lucille Ball was America’s sweetheart through her television role in the “I Love Lucy” show. Her career was nearly derailed because of the allegation promoted by a gossip columnist of the day that Lucy was a “Communist”. She was able to quickly fend off this allegation and move on with her professional life.

Many others were not so fortunate. The film is now availabe on Amazon Prime and in selected theaters.

Excerpted from The Chronicle – Mick LaSalle 12.21.2021

The bottom line on “Being the Ricardos” is that it’s irresistible. It’s an invitation to go behind the scenes of the “I Love Lucy” show and to see what Lucille Ball and Desi Arnaz were really like. It’s also an invitation to travel back to the 1950s, with writer-director Aaron Sorkin as your guide.

Being the Ricardos II 12.21.2021.jpg
Lucille Ball and Desi Arnaz

To succeed here, Sorkin first had to solve one big challenge before all the other elements would fall into place. He had to come up with a story. Fortunately for Sorkin, he knows something that other screenwriters and would-be screenwriters don’t know: the difference between what’s a story and what’s merely interesting.

It’s the week that began with gossip columnist and red-baiter Walter Winchell obliquely accusing Ball — the most popular TV personality in America — of being a communist. That charge was untrue, but not baseless.

When she was very young, Ball checked a box to join the Communist Party as a favor to a leftist relative. Beyond that, she never did anything — no meetings, no secret handshakes, no speeches extolling the U.S.S.R. as a worker’s paradise. But in the early 1950s, the era of Joe McCarthy, careers were being destroyed for less.

Sorkin uses this crisis as the spine for “Being the Ricardos,” and with that in place, he can go anywhere he wants to go. He can do a flashback to show Lucy and Desi’s courtship. He can introduce the network’s reaction to Lucy’s pregnancy. He can concentrate on the stress point of the Lucy-Desi marriage, namely Desi’s infidelity.

Being the Ricardos III 12.21.2021
Lucille Ball and her counterpart Nicole Kidman

For example, it’s interesting that William Frawley and Vivian Vance, who played Fred and Ethel Mertz on the sitcom, detested each other. It’s interesting that Ball insisted that Vance remain slightly overweight and never look glamorous. It’s interesting how Lucy and Desi met, and how her movie career was only so-so, and how radio became her launching pad for a career in television.

Sorkin finds ways to include and dramatize all those interesting elements. But he doesn’t try to locate his story in any of them, either because they’re not consequential enough, or they’re not compressed enough (that is, they take place over too long a stretch of time). Instead, Sorkin finds his story in a series of events that took place over the course of about a week, in which the futures of Lucy, Desi and “I Love Lucy” hung in the balance.

Being the Ricardos IV 12.21.2021.jpg
Javier Bardem and his counterpart Desi Arnaz

Javier Bardem captures Desi’s macho aura and magnetism, but he lacks his humor. When he sings “Babaloo” and “Cuban Pete,” it’s impossible not to miss Arnaz’s distinct tenor voice. Still, acting isn’t impersonation, and Bardem functions well as Desi within the world that Sorkin creates.

As for Sorkin, he is establishing himself as a major filmmaker of Americana. He did the 1990s with “The American President” and “West Wing,” the Vietnam era with “The Trial of the Chicago 7,” and now he’s done the ’50s. I’d like to see what he could do with the ’30s or ’40s.

Review: ‘Being the Ricardos’ is an irresistible film about Lucy and Desi

“Fighting the so-called war on drugs where has it gotten us?” asks DA Boudin

Liz and Lee Heidhues 12.20.2021 (UPDATED)

DA Chesa Boudin ran on a campaign platform to use the office of chief prosecutor in a different manner than the traditional law and order approach to crime. 

Now he faces a recall, calling into question the very fiber of San Francisco’s “progressive” reputation.  To DA Boudin’s credit he is standing by the platform on which he ran and was elected two years ago.

During his two years in office DA Boudin has brought about a humane system of dealing with criminal defendants.  He has worked empirically, epistemically to transform the ‘lock ’em up’ approach to criminal justice.  He has worked to implement his reform policies amidst the obstacles of the now two year long Pandemic.

DA Boudin has successfully managed within the constraints of the Pandemic to decrease the jail population and to perform his job within the severely truncated Court system.

Excerpted from The San Francisco Chronicle and SF Gate 12.20.2021

District Attorney Chesa Boudin, along with other elected officials and activists, protested Monday against Mayor London Breed’s public safety push meant to flood the Tenderloin with police and crackdown on drug dealers and people who use drugs.

Chesa Tenderloin IV12.20.2021.jpg
San Francisco District Attorney Chesa Boudin speaks during a press conference in protest of Mayor London Breed’s plan for more policing and enforcement of laws that could affect drug users in the Tenderloin neighborhood on Monday, Dec. 20, 2021, in San Francisco. Boudin urged Breed to put more money into housing and treatment to get at the roots causes of crime. (Gabrielle Lurie/San Francisco Chronicle via AP)Gabrielle Lurie/AP

“If arrests and prosecutions alone could solve the drug crisis in this country or in this city, it would have been solved long ago,” Boudin said. “We’ve invested over a trillion dollars in fighting the so-called war on drugs, and where has it gotten us?”

Boudin’s presence at an afternoon news conference held by opponents of the plan calls into question whether the mayor can succeed in this push and pits Breed against the city’s top prosecutor.

Chesa I 11.8.2019.png
Candidate Boudin in 2019

Boudin’s decision to join the protest comes as he faces a recall election next year. It underscores the debate in San Francisco about how to deal not just with crime, but with the homelessness and addiction crises.

The news conference comes as Boudin, whose 2019 election was not supported by Breed, faces a recall election in June put on the ballot by detractors who say he is soft on criminals. Boudin’s office has countered the criticism with examples of successful crackdowns on retail theft and other criminal operations. But his remarks Monday made clear his position on going after people who have substance use problems or mental health issues.

Boudin said the “raw human suffering” he sees in the neighborhood outrages him. But using outdated methods won’t make people any safer, and the city has other options, said Boudin, who worked in the public defender’s office before becoming DA.

Last week, Breed said that she hoped the district attorney would prosecute people arrested under her plan. But it appears that progressive Boudin may not cooperate.

Judges also play a role, since they have discretion beyond the district attorney to release someone from custody before their trial, which could influence whether that person returns to the streets.

It didn’t appear as of last week that the Mayor had met with either Boudin or the head of the courts.

Chesa and Mayor Breed 1.21.2021.jpg
DA Boudin and Mayor Breed

At the news conference held at addiction treatment center HealthRight360 in SoMa, leaders including Board of Supervisors President Shamann Walton called for the Mayor to instead quickly ramp up “evidence-based” alternatives to policing for people who use drugs, including more treatment and housing. The city has been chronically short of drug and mental health treatment beds and housing for the homeless.

While city leaders and residents are divided about the best way forward, some Tenderloin families and business owners have been pleading for safer and cleaner streets for months in the face of shootings and open-air drug use.

https://www.sfchronicle.com/sf/article/D-A-Chesa-Boudin-joins-critics-of-Breed-s-16717418.php

https://www.sfgate.com/news/article/San-Francisco-DA-others-denounce-mayor-s-plan-16718160.php